Tarte Best in Faux Lash Fibers + Mascara

tarte's Double Duty Beauty collection

affiliate link small

Moi…? Review a fiber lash product…? Anyone who knows me is probably shocked right now, as they know how I am opposed to fiber products near the eyes. Not only do many of them look either tarantula-like or clumpy as Hell, but there are health concerns as well. While there are some decent products available, there are also some really bad ones, especially cheapo knock-off products from China. After horror stories of irritation and eye infections, I have avoided this type of product like the plague.

However, fiber lash products have become very popular, with a lot of companies making them now. I have had so many people ask me about this type of thing; seemingly every day someone would ask. So, when I received the Tarte Best in Faux fibers in a reward box, and Missy at Sephora promised this would not give me clumps or tarantula lashes, I decided to bite the bullet and try Best in Faux out. You asked, I shall deliver!


At first, I wasn’t going to go near this stuff, even though I didn’t pay for it. But then, I found out the fibers were made out of hypoallergenic nylon, which is less likely to cause irritation than fibers made out of natural or other substances (see “Natural Isn’t Always Better” here). Less irritation is definitely a plus when dealing with the eye area- not to mention my dreadful allergies! Please keep in mind, though, that just because these are hypoallergenic and opthamologist-tested does not mean you, or anybody, will not have problems. If you wear contacts or have any eye issues or sensitivities, make sure to check with your doctor before using this type of product- no matter what the content.

Like other fiber lash products, this is a two-step process. The first step is to apply mascara, then fibers, then mascara again. The set comes with Tarte’s best-selling Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara, but you can use any kind you choose. I find this mascara to be too dry, so I opted to use Diorshow instead. Tarte recommends applying mascara first, then the fibers. You should apply the fibers only from the middle of the lashes to the end, do not apply at the base of the lashes. After applying the fibers, apply another coat of mascara. You can repeat these steps more than once for a more dramatic effect. In order to avoid the dreaded clumpiness that comes with many fiber products, make sure you have a lash comb on hand. A fan brush is also helpful to brush away stray fibers. I also found that it’s helpful to keep your eye partially closed to avoid getting the fibers into your eye.


Overall, these fibers worked as advertised, and my eyelashes looked quite nice. Would I recommend this stuff? That would still be a “no.” It seemed like only a matter of time before a fiber (or multiple fibers) fell off into my eyes. In the photo, the eye without fibers has just one coat of mascara. Another coat or two, and it would be nearly as effective as the fibers. Maybe my lashes still wouldn’t have looked quite as long and full as they did with the fibers, but a set of falsies would be much quicker and easier. Not to mention my other half’s reaction: when I showed him eyes and told him I actually tried lash fibers- he said, “They look nice, but they will still fall into your eyes, then you’ll get an infection and your eye will fall out!” Thanks a lot, Jerry…lol 😉

Nevertheless, if you are one of the many people out there who like fiber lash products, this is a great buy. You get both the mascara and the fibers for just $20.  You can also get them separate (with the mascara and fibers unattached in a wand) for the same price.


No mascara


Left (my right eye) has one coat of Diorshow mascara. Right (my left eye) has Diorshow mascara with one coat of Tarte Best in Faux lash fibers.

Shop tarte's Best Sellers and receive Free Samples plus, Free Shipping on $40+

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links.



  1. I think I know what your all talking about. I really like that mascara and even though its more expensive its worth it. Its there other stuff that’s not good. The rest is low quality. When I run out I might try the Tarte kind or I might see what else is out there.

    • Hi Erna! It’s nice to have someone here on the other end of the spectrum! This goes along with what I have heard from people I know who have tried it- some love it, some don’t. I’m glad it works for you! If you try any other kinds, let us know! 🙂

  2. I’m so glad I saw this, I was wanting to try the [EDITED] but I didn’t want to have to deal with one of those presenters. I had to unfollow a friend who is a presenter just because I got soooo tired of reading all the stuff about [EDITED]. My friends who tried it said the presenters don’t leave you alone and it gets worse if you buy it. And if you try to return it they make you feel guilty and tell you your friend will have to pay the company money back! I am going to go to Ulta when I get off work to get some of the tarte!

    • Glad to be of service, Delila! I’m so sorry you had that experience- I agree some consultants can be a bit “much.” That goes for all products, not just this one. But some of them are great and very helpful! Glad you are going to try the Tarte- I think you will like them!

  3. I bought [EDITED OUT] from a party a friend had and they were terrible. I never thought of it looking like tarantulas but it does! And if it doesn’t look like spiders it just looks like giant clumps. Can’t believe I spent 40 bucks for those with shipping and tax! I sent mine back but I didn’t get the shipping back. So I will try the Tarte lashes because they are half the price and can get free shipping.

    • Hi Caren! Glad you are going to give the Tarte Best in Faux a try- hopefully it will work out for you! There are so many great products out there now, that there is something for everyone. I think it’s just a matter of finding what works best for you 🙂

  4. More than 1 step for mascara… No thanks I’m a single mom I got very very little “ME” time … I’m not trying to make my “schedule” any more complicated! … You try keeping a 2 year old out of the toilet while trying to apply “fibers” lmao not gonna happen .. I like what I got it’s fast and works great!

    • I knew right away what you would think, Gina, and it’s about time you comment on something…lol! If you’re talking about the Benefit Roller Lash- I agree, it’s fantastic! Jerry’s sister was needing waterproof mascara, so we told her about how you actually needed eye makeup remover for it, so it’s perfect for her, too! 🙂

Comments are closed.